Agriculture

The White Man's food and tooth decay

This is Killjoy Week at Hunter-Gatherer.  I've railed on the evils of gourmet cupcakes and candy's powerful sway on children.  I'd love nothing more than to villify raindrops on roses or whiskers on kittens based on health grounds.  (Hmmm...both are too sweet?)  Okay, so you aren't splurging on cupcakes everyday, you might not have kids, and if you do, Halloween only comes once a year -- why does this matter?

Let's take a look at cavities.  There is clear evidence -- archaelogical and anthropological -- showing that hunter-gatherers have dramatically fewer cavities than agriculturalists who came after.  Here is data based on skeletons in North America around the transition to agriculture.  Before agriculture, fewer than 5% showed signs of a cavity at death.  That jumps to over 20% with agriculture (around 500-1,000 A.D. in this case).  Remember that these people aren't eating hard candy and Twizzlers, they're primarily adding more grains and grain-products to their diet.
 
 
Full paper here, via Nat Geo's Spencer Wells and his new book, Pandora's Seed: The Unforeseen Cost of Civilization.  
 
Of course, this is old hat to people in the paleo community, primarily due to the research of Dr. Weston A. Price, a dentist from Cleveland who traveled the world in the 1930s looking for isolated peoples living their traditional diet.  His mangum opus, Nutrition and Physical Degeneration, documented case after case of healthy teeth among people eating their indigenous diet, and those same people ravaged by dental problems as soon as they started eating the White Man's food.  Dental problems were one of the worst ongoing health epidemics in the world leading up to regular tooth brushing and fluoride in our water supply not so long ago.
 
Looking at the pictures below reminds me of those frightening before and after photos of meth addicts.  At left, healthy people who eat traditionally.  At right, people from the same tribe who eat the White Man's food.  
 
Don't forget to brush your teeth.  And beware the White Man's food.
 
 
                          

 

Alcohol and the seeds of agriculture

Most people assume that humans first domesticated grains for food -- but what if we first domesticated grains for drink?  Beer, specifically.  That's one suggestion of the new book by Patrick McGovern, Uncorking the Past.

Wild grains would have been time-intensive to harvest, difficult to process into an edible form, and would have been poor in nutrient quality relative to other available foods -- so why try?  McGovern suggests that grains may have been valued for purposes of intoxication first, and only later as a source of food.  Der Spiegel has the details:

"Archaeologists have long pondered the question of which came first, bread or beer. McGovern surmises that these prehistoric humans didn't initially have the ability to master the very complicated process of brewing beer. However, they were even more incapable of baking bread, for which wild grains are extremely unsuitable. They would have had first to separate the tiny grains from the chaff, with a yield hardly worth the great effort. If anything, the earliest bakers probably made nothing more than a barely palatable type of rough bread, containing the unwanted addition of the grain's many husks."

...

"As early as around 9,000 years ago, long before the invention of the wheel, inhabitants of the Neolithic village Jiahu in China were brewing a type of mead with an alcohol content of 10 percent..."

...

"Lacking any knowledge of chemistry, prehistoric humans eager for the intoxicating effects of alcohol apparently mixed clumps of rice with saliva in their mouths to break down the starches in the grain and convert them into malt sugar. These pioneering brewers would then spit the chewed up rice into their brew. Husks and yeasty foam floated on top of the liquid, so they used long straws to drink from narrow necked jugs. Alcohol is still consumed this way in some regions of China."

McGovern is a bio-molecular archaeologist at the University of Pennsylvania.  (That's a fancy name for Alcohol Studies.)  McGovern uses trace residues from pottery found at ancient archaeological sites to identify the ingredients.

Even better, McGovern and Dogfish Head Brewery teamed up to recreate some of the earliest alcoholic beverages ever discovered.  Dogfish Head now offers three beers as part of their Ancient Ales line.  Check out each beer's homepage for additional background.

Theobroma - Based on pottery fragments in Honduras from 1,200 BC, the earliest known example of using cocoa for human consumption.

Midas Touch - Based on ingredients found in the tomb of Kind Midas and an ancient Turkish recipe.

Chateau Jiahu - Based on jars found in a Neolithic village in China 9,000 years ago.

For a bit more background on the brewing story, try here.  

(Thanks to Christal for the pointer.)

 

Syndicate content